I think what you put on the screen depends very much on your audience. I have one customer that has roaming technicians that assist the operators. They want 'big' flashing lights when the machine is not running. Another has managers that look at numbers and love digital panel meters.
Personally, I like numbers and charts. Production rates might also benefit some. For those that use statistical process control the trending charts are what they use to optimize their processes. I also like a little color but I use it sparingly. I try to add just enough to give the screen a little flavor without being overwhelming.
When given total freedom of the design I almost always try to show as much P&ID as possible with pertinent data . I don't do all that much with graphics as I believe that should not be the focal point of the screen and sometimes it takes up valuable space. Also I'm not very good with graphics.